I knew it was over in the first 15 minutes. The Maryland Charter Boat Association and the Delmarva Fisheries Association came out swinging. I wasn't there but the room was stacked. I could hear it in their voices. The came out strong about the economic impact any cuts would bring to their businesses, their families, their children, and future generations. And they were convincing. There were other speakers as well, Tom Fote brought up catfish, Ross Squire tried to turn the mood, but it was too late. The Chesapeake guys set the table for the finisher, none other than Adam Nowasky. New Jersey's Adam Nowalksy. He entered the game like Mariano Rivera and shut the game down.
By then the meeting was about two hours old. It was almost time for lunch. And then it wasn't. Nowalksy dropped a Status Quo bomb that was more of a magnet than an incendiary device. It attracted people to it. Kind of like a bug light. Now let me say this of Nowalsky. I only met him once. Have heard him more times than I care to. I oppose just about everything he says. I think he's shady. But, to give credit where credit is due, boy is he good. I don't know what magical powers he has but he puts the malook on people in those fisheries management meetings.
If Nowalksy is your ride or die, then you're in good hands. Rob a bank with him, he wouldn't budge. Need to bury a body, "I'll grab the shovel". Any of you guys or girls thinking of cheating on your spouse, call Nowalsky when you get caught. He'll convince the wounded it never happened, even if they walked in on it. He's that good. But I want to vomit when I hear that slow almost condescending voice of his. He may the best guy, when I speak of him in it's his role as ongoing proxy for Senator Vin Gopal.
So he blew it up. Status Quo, WITH, the formulation of a kumbiya panel "of good people", who will put out a white paper, in like three years, looking in depth as to what is all wrong and what we can do, together, as one big striped bass killing family. I again, wanted to puke. The "Work group" will do this AFTER the 2027 benchmark assessment. Remember, the last one was done in 2024. And since then the ASMFC has kicked the can down the road, and guess what, they did it again.
I knew it was all over when I heard the speakers with that Southern drawl thanking Nowalksy. The fix was in. This wasn't a surprise, it was probably decided, and already known, way before this meeting. If this was an old school union meeting or convention Nowalksy would have opened up his hotel room door and found a nice bottle of whiskey and two of Delaware's most sought after call girls. I at least hope they treated him to a rockfish dinner before he headed back to Jersey.
Kudos to Massachusetts own Nicola Meserve. She came back with and amendment (above) to Nowalksy's ammendemt saying keep the Work Group B.S., but let's go with that 12% reduction. Is was a chance to do SOMETHING to stop the bleeding. Well that went to vote and didn't pass. 5-11. Nowalsky's then went to vote and passed, 13-3. Status Quo, or no changes to the regulations, for 2026.
Well the victory went to the other side, and there were sides. This was purely commercial vs recreational. And the commercial, and the for-hires, won. What is a positive is that, like I have been saying, and am on record at the PA Public Hearing, is that commercials should include the for-hire industry, and wait till their numbers cross the aisle with them. That's every head and charter boat out there. Watch what you wish for.
So who lost? Well the striped bass did in a big way. Just because every fish the boat guys are getting are over 40 inches doesn't mean the entire picture is bright. The YOY indexes are set and have been for years. There may be big fish out there but what about the small ones? The ASMFC, which I loathe, is in the business, they should get out of, fisheries management. They can't chase the guy down in Maryland pouring Scotts fertilizer on his bayfront lawn. Their idea of reductions, is a good one. Less dead fish hopefully will mean more fish.
That argument of owning a charter operation and it's your right, well easy. My first boss in photography was my friend Carl at the Red Bank Register. When that closed he moved to The News Tribune. When that went belly up....he went to school and changed careers. At 40! Things don't last forever. Adapt and overcome. Maybe charter captaining isn't sustainable. How's those daily print newspapers doing these days?
Well the winners. Nowalksy, for one. I feel like a kid who's on the losing Little League team and your mom is telling you to go congratulate the winners. I hate to do it, but give credit where it's due. The commercial and for-hire sectors, soon to be glommed together, win. They have another year to hammer down on the 2018 year class of fish now.....enjoy that one for the table. And New Jersey as well, they keep their Bonus Tag Program.
And then there's Emilie Franke. She runs the ship. Went to every public meeting. She even tried early on to discuss what the overall vibe was from the public. Let's me honest, and now I'll agree, nobody give a f%$k about you or your dumb speech, email, or from letter. If she came in thinking that 12% would be on the table and the discussions would be on how to meet it, well, she must have been very disappointed. Her job was easy today. It was a landslide victory before lunch.
On October 6th I penned a post about 'Just Say No to Status Quo". I told my buds not to worry about No-Target, and yes there may be some days that are close, but the real threat to conservation is Status Quo. I had to say I saw it coming, but I did. The Dark Side has been working this for months. And who's to blame? Well the ASMFC is. Most of their data came from NOAA's MRIP volunteer FES survey's, which are about as scientific as asking people in church if they farted today. Once you make that the backbone of your argument, and sniff out the possibility that mortality is way les then expected, and raise doubt in people's minds, then you find yourself taking roll call for a Status Quo, which passed.
People are celebrating. I really don't know why. We can't measure predation, or natural causes, or environmental factors, but we know they all exist. What we should be celebrating were the adults in the room who made the hard decisions, and sacrifices, for the striped bass, and the people who enjoy to fish for, and even eat them. We were looking for a pause in the action to allow the bass to catch up. What we're doing now isn't sustainable, especially for the fish.