
The fall run hasn't even hit full swing yet and I'm talking the winter doldrum fly fishing related shows. Before I skewer the International Fly Tying Symposium (IFTS) let me talk about The Fly Fishing Show (TFFS). The year it kicks off in Marlborough. Massachusetts January 16, 17, & 18 and then hits the ti-state area and Edison January 23, 24, & 25. So put it on your calendar. I'd say book your rooms early to get the discounted rate, but remember, like we saw last year, breakfast is NOT
included! You get $2 off the 20 something dollar bill for some okay get out the door eats. It was a shit show each morning during last year's The Fly Fishing Show watching as people handed over their "vouchers" only to be told breakfast wasn't part of the room rate.
Now the International Fly Tying Symposium. I'm going to try and be nice. Timing. Not good. It's the heat of the fall run and most working, like Monday through Friday, fly anglers will be looking to get into the bass blitz searching that weekend. On Sunday the Giants will be at home vs the Packers so you'll lose that crowd. Last year's attendance was, to me, weak.
Last year was the 33rd year that Chuck Furminsky has run the show. Hats off to him for getting it and TFFS started and doing it for decades now. Through thick and thin it comes and goes every year. Through venue changes, industry changes, and things like Covid it has survived. Hey nothing is like it used to be and that includes industry shows as well. But the truth is somethings need to change, or they need to fade out before it's just kicking a dead horse. And, in my opinion, the IFTS is on life support.
I hate to say remember when it was good, like really good. It may not have had the TFFS numbers, but it was solid and was a no-miss for many of the vendors and for seasoned and amateur fly tyers alike. It was the place where you could score good materials, meet the legends and professionals, and buy stuff you'd never take out of the package. I know because I have things sitting around my fly tying desk that I've never opened, but just needed to have.
There's nothing like running your fingers through materials in person and visiting BuzFly's and Flatwing's booths can really get your fly tying juices going. Couple that with the good picking through the bin booths and there was always a score to be had.
The Collins booth, 2009 IFTS And then there was the Collins and Keogh booths which always drew between 50 -125 dollars out of my pocket each November. If I wasn't on the inside of the show I'd be one of the first in line to get a shot at the bulk bins, knowing the show attendees already had the first pickings.
There's nothing like good advertising, social media , and an email blitz to get things hyped up. Months ago I started getting those on my various feeds. While they are good, they have to be honest. In one of this years emails the recipients are informed that, " This year's symposium promises to be the largest and most comprehensive in its 34-year history......". Wow, that's a big promise, one that I don't think can be delivered.
On the IFTS web page potential attendees were notified that Hareline won't be making the show this year, but Stockard Fly Fishing will be. I've heard the two- Joe's, Calcevechia, Saltwater Custom Flies, and Cordiero, Flatwing, will be sitting this one out. Brad at BuzFly better be up to his knees in bucktails because he'll be about the biggest materials-draw at the show. Will Keogh and AHREX show? I don't know. And will all the vice companies who've been in a male member measuring stick competition at all the shows for the last five years still try and see who's boss? We'll see. Last year they were there, I'm kinda thinking not so much moving forward.
For you to attend it's $20 bucks for the Saturday, and $30 for the weekend. If you don't stop to chat, last year I spent an hour with Bob Clouser, or pick though Brad's tails, you could do the room in an hour. But for the vendors it's a risk vs gain, return on investment, kind of business deal. It costs a lot in time and money to attend these shows. Commuting, lodging, eating, and then cutting Chuck in on the profits. If the interest, and more importantly the $$$$, isn't there then they won't be. A talented tier who's selling flies along fly tyer row, like legitimately not on the down-low, can turn a wheeled-in bin full of flies into a decent haul for the two-day event.
I always buy a fly or two, usually from a young kid showing off his wares. The above trio was at the Long Island Fly Fishing Expo a few years back. I stuffed a couple of their Flexo Crabs into my pocket and did well with them sight fishing on the Vineyard.
And remember when the IFTS was stacked with the best tiers from across the globe? Just think of the names that made the trek to the no-miss show over the years. I won't mention names as to not discredit those tiers that do the show each year, but there were some big names, and they draw attendees. Rightfully the IFTS advertises, at least this year, who will be there.
They published a list of "About 100 professional and amateur fly tiers- amongst the best the world has to offer...." as bait to drum up interest. Yes, a lot of good people on that list, but good amateurs don't increase bodies in the narrow aisles like the big guns do.
So what does this keyboard critic/ Danny downer think? Well, to be honest I thought last year was it. With Bobby's passing and the show struggling to meet the attendees needs, I thought it was time to gracefully whip finish the show. That's at least what we've known it to be, not saying, it couldn't be changed to meet expectations and with the times. So, Mr. Know It All, what would you do?
I'd get rid of the "International" in the International Fly Tying Symposium. Having a few guys fly over each fall, mostly to fish blitzing bass from a boat, with the Shore Catch guys, isn't cutting it. I'd make it a local event. Kind of like the Long Island Fly Fishing Expo is doing. While the bigger The Fly Fishing Show may not be the place to be hyper try-state area focused, this show could be. Let's just take the encatchment area the IFTS serves. Let's say New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania. Any fly tiers or fly fishermen and women, and youngsters, from those states? Any good water? Any good species? From trout on the Upper Delaware to every stocky stream, to stripers, albies and bluefish in the salt, to smallmouths and snakeheads and panfish, we have it all. Target that crowd.
The show show be a beginners show. Cater to what this industry and this sport needs- new blood. Fly tying and fishing, like Bobby said, is all about teaching and sharing the experience and knowledge. Target those cross-overs looking to go from fresh to salt. Run beginner classes- affordable ones- to get people behind the vices. Yes, you could even run kids types seminars- yuk, but it's what we need. Have solid and local presentations to get the local interest brewing. If we want to learn about fly fishing in Ireland and Patagonia then we'll come back in January for TFFS.
It could also be a place that showcase the local clubs. There's Trout Unlimited with all kinds of chapters in the three states, other freshwater clubs, and saltwater clubs like Bayshore, Atlantic, Coastal, and Salty. Rather then just have them lining the walls and filling up space to look like the shows, especially TFFS, are bigger then they are, have them do presentations. How about a fly tying competition between them? I have to be honest I'm done with the club fly raffles. I know they make money for a good cause but they have much more to offer. Give them a chance, and the venue to show it, not just sitting there inviting people over for a raffle, or a mint or a 1/4 inch piece of a Snickers in a wrapper. Maybe running a hyper-local show like this may get the Moy's to unload their store, Tightlines, into Somerset, because it would be worth it for them. With Orvis Princeton closing there's not many Garden State shops left.
So, remember, the dinosaurs and daily newspapers went extinct. Sadly, the IFTS could face the same fate if they don't change. There's like 10 billion people within 100 miles of Somerset. Having 18 people in line to get in 5 minutes before the show opens isn't a good indicator of the
show's relevance and interest. I will be there again in two weeks, mostly to keep abreast of things New Jersey and fly fishing, but also for chance encounters with friends, or even one of the legends, like I did with Clouser last year. I said it last year after the show. Years ago there would be a crowd around his booth all day long. The people that were there, I'm not talking bad, they
just didn't know who Bob Clouser was. I had him to myself for an hour at his booth during the late morning on Saturday. I left with something special that he gave me and that made my $20 admission fee well worth it. We'll see what this year's show brings.